Are Vaishnavas Idolators?

Abstract

The article "Are Vaishnavas Idolators?" by Kenneth Valpey (Krishna Kshetra Das) explores the charge of idolatry against Vaishnava practices from the vantage point of Jewish theological frameworks. Engaging with the concept of "idolatry" as interpreted in Judaic tradition, the author juxtaposes five core accusations—betrayal, representation, error, false practice, and myth—with Vaishnava murti-sevā and bhakti theology, particularly within Caitanyaite Vaishnavism. Through comparative theology and philosophical reflection, the article contends that Vaishnava devotional image worship resists simplistic classification as idolatry, challenging Western assumptions and inviting nuanced interreligious dialogue.